December 05
2006
The Intellectual Obscurantism Campaign
» Posted on December 5, 2006 11:15 AM » Category: Buffoons

It's not often I read a piece by Germaine Greer and want to shout my agreement with every dot and comma of it, but her piece today against the somewhat dreadful Plain English Campaign is bang on.

(Oliver Kamm has been fighting the good fight.)


MessageSpace
Comments

Classic Greer.

Conceited – How dare he criticise my wonderful prose!
Bitchy – He only has an Open University degree!
Wrong – Kant as a model of lucid prose.

Kant is an outstandingly bad writer (as anybody who knows anything about German philosophy knows). It is hardly surprising that Greer refuses to accept that her prose is anything other than golden, but do not praise her for it!

Stated by: Chris Goodman on December 5, 2006 1:26 PM

The fact that Greer makes a gratuitous reference to a philosopher that she (and evidently you) know nothing about is a neat demonstration of precisely what you seek to refute i.e. obscurity of language disguising banality of thought.

Stated by: Chris Goodman on December 5, 2006 2:17 PM

'Kant is an outstandingly bad writer (as anybody who knows anything about German philosophy knows)'

- indeed, and you can include Germans who have read him in the original.

And the bit that's not from Kant - 'creates a discontinuity' - is even worse, a lazy 'look, I'm an Intellectual' cliche. She may not quite have deserved the gong but she certainly protests too much.

Stated by: Cyrus on December 7, 2006 11:06 AM

Classic Greer! That is an oxymoron. The woman is the pits and I insult the name woman by applying it to her. She's never written anything of substance which can't be picked to pieces. She's an offence to creation.

Stated by: James on December 21, 2006 6:06 PM
Post a comment

    


    •