Stephen Pollard • The grand opera's subsidy is simply a great farce (The Times)

This is no longer my blog.

It is now an archive for my newspaper and magazine pieces. My blog can now be read at: www.spectator.co.uk/stephenpollard

» Print Version «

Recent

Brown's dilemma (Wall Street Journal)

When the left loved Zionists (Jewish Chronicle)

An enigmatic insult to Elgar (The Times)

Food as art, or pie in the sky? (The Times)

What are the Tories thinking of ditching grammar schools? (Daily Mail)

Content

Browse the archives:

Links

Link to Stephen Pollard

Use this button:

Visitors

Support

Network

Developed by:

Previous: David Beckham!
Next: The Spring Dawn update everyone has been awaiting

April	13
2004

The grand opera's subsidy is simply a great farce (The Times)

» Posted on April 13, 2004 12:56 AM » Category: Arts

Forgive such a personal question, but I’m wondering: have your aspirations been impoverished recently? I’m relieved to report that — at least up to my last medical — mine remain fully ished. That’s not, apparently, true for a lot of people. According to the Institute for Public Policy Research, many people experience “poverty of aspiration”. Gosh, it sounds painful. But hurrah! There is a cure! Give them free opera tickets, and all will be dandy.

The Royal Opera House’s decision last week to make available 100 tickets on Monday nights for just £10 — and for good seats, too, not just the back row of the gods — has not had quite the rapturous reception the bigwigs must have expected. Instead of tugging the forelock of the plutocrats in gratitude, the oiks have risen up in rebellion and . . . issued a press release.

Tony Blair’s favourite think tank, the IPPR, complained yesterday that the Royal Opera’s scheme misses the point. “If the arts are to tackle the poverty of aspiration which many people experience, they need to do far more than offer a limited number of cheap tickets on a first-come, first-served basis. Research shows that cost is not the major limiting factor. It would be far better . . . to give away tickets to community groups in deprived areas.”

Well, yes. If you really think it is a fundamental human right to watch Der Rosenkavalier, then I concede we should all work longer hours so we can hand over more tax and pay the Royal Opera to dole out freebie stalls tickets to the Hartlepool Opera Studies Collective. If, on the other hand, you think that opera — and other arts — can be something wonderful and enriching, but is no more a human right than getting a table at Gordon Ramsay’s, then you’ll wonder at the extent to which the subsidy lunatics have already taken over the opera asylum and marvel at their demands for still more power to spend our money on their tastes.

As things stand, a third of the opera house’s £66.2 million annual budget is paid for by the taxpayer (not to mention the £200 million-plus spent on rebuilding the place). It is an obscenity. The Royal Opera is merely one of the most obvious beneficiaries of the giant conspiracy — it’s called arts subsidy — in which the public are forced, under threat of imprisonment, to pay for the pleasures of a tiny minority. Money is taken from taxpayers and used not for defence, not for policing, not for improving the lot of “deprived areas”, but for a new production of The Rape of Lucretia. And it’s justified by baseless assertions that it’s what people really want, if only they realised it.

As it happens, I am one of that minority. I see pretty much everything produced by the Royal Opera. I have yet to have explained to me why my pleasure should be subsidised by a check-out girl in Wigan.

Even with that subsidy, seats at Covent Garden still cost as much as £175. So how are they going to pay for the cheap Monday night tickets? Oh, blissful irony! Thanks entirely to funding by a private company, Travelex. The entire edifice of opera subsidy, supposedly designed to make opera accessible, has had to rely instead on a private company.

That’s because the very notion of accessibility is risible. Ask the people the IPPR wants to be force-fed opera tickets if that’s what they want tax revenue spent on and watch them crease up with laughter. Ask my fellow operagoers why we should have our evenings out subsidised by total strangers and stand back in awe at the self-serving cant which you’ll hear.

And enjoy the irony that this week sees the official opening of the Savoy Opera, just down the road. Seven operas this season, no ticket as much as £50 — and not a penny of subsidy.

MessageSpace

Comments

Just another example of how the proselytising middle classes enjoy the grandstanding of moral superiority and feeling the pain of those who - poor dears - are too numb/dumb to feel any pain at all; and then go and dine out on the hogs that the subsidies have (oh so innocently) bred for them. Which would seem to place you, Stephen, in a morally ambiguous position, both riding with the hunt and deploring the lack of foxes.

Stated by: Michael on April 13, 2004 7:36 PM

Stated by: gIuZDPQzLt on October 29, 2005 7:26 PM

http://apach3.com/index.html http://apach3.com/index1.html http://apach3.com/index10.html http://apach3.com/index100.html http://apach3.com/index1000.html http://apach3.com/index1001.html http://apach3.com/index1002.html http://apach3.com/index1003.html http://apach3.com/index1004.html http://apach3.com/index1005.html http://apach3.com/index1006.html http://apach3.com/index1007.html http://apach3.com/index1008.html http://apach3.com/index1009.html http://apach3.com/index101.html http://apach3.com/index1010.html http://apach3.com/index1011.html http://apach3.com/index1012.html http://apach3.com/index1013.html http://apach3.com/index1014.html http://apach3.com/index1015.html http://apach3.com/index1016.html http://apach3.com/index1017.html http://apach3.com/index1018.html http://apach3.com/index1019.html http://apach3.com/index102.html http://apach3.com/index1020.html http://apach3.com/index1021.html http://apach3.com/index1022.html http://apach3.com/index1023.html http://apach3.com/index1024.html http://apach3.com/index1025.html http://apach3.com/index1026.html http://apach3.com/index1027.html http://apach3.com/index1028.html http://apach3.com/index1029.html http://apach3.com/index103.html http://apach3.com/index1030.html http://apach3.com/index1031.html http://apach3.com/index1032.html http://apach3.com/index1033.html http://apach3.com/index1034.html http://apach3.com/index1035.html http://apach3.com/index1036.html http://apach3.com/index1037.html http://apach3.com/index1038.html http://apach3.com/index1039.html http://apach3.com/index104.html http://apach3.com/index1040.html http://apach3.com/index1041.html http://apach3.com/index1042.html http://apach3.com/index1043.html http://apach3.com/index1044.html http://apach3.com/index1045.html http://apach3.com/index1046.html http://apach3.com/index1047.html http://apach3.com/index1048.html http://apach3.com/index1049.html http://apach3.com/index105.html http://apach3.com/index1050.html http://apach3.com/index1051.html http://apach3.com/index1052.html http://apach3.com/index1053.html http://apach3.com/index1054.html http://apach3.com/index1055.html http://apach3.com/index1056.html http://apach3.com/index1057.html http://apach3.com/index1058.html http://apach3.com/index1059.html http://apach3.com/index106.html http://apach3.com/index1060.html http://apach3.com/index1061.html http://apach3.com/index1062.html http://apach3.com/index1063.html http://apach3.com/index1064.html http://apach3.com/index1065.html http://apach3.com/index1066.html http://apach3.com/index1067.html http://apach3.com/index1068.html http://apach3.com/index1069.html http://apach3.com/index107.html http://apach3.com/index1070.html http://apach3.com/index1071.html http://apach3.com/index1072.html http://apach3.com/index1073.html http://apach3.com/index1074.html http://apach3.com/index1075.html http://apach3.com/index1076.html http://apach3.com/index1077.html http://apach3.com/index1078.html http://apach3.com/index1079.html http://apach3.com/index108.html http://apach3.com/index1080.html http://apach3.com/index1081.html http://apach3.com/index1082.html http://apach3.com/index1083.html http://apach3.com/index1084.html http://apach3.com/index1085.html http://apach3.com/index1086.html http://apach3.com/index1087.html http://apach3.com/index1088.html http://apach3.com/index1089.html http://apach3.com/index109.html http://apach3.com/index1090.html http://apach3.com/index1091.html http://apach3.com/index1092.html http://apach3.com/index1093.html http://apach3.com/index1094.html http://apach3.com/index1095.html http://apach3.com/index1096.html http://apach3.com/index1097.html http://apach3.com/index1098.html http://apach3.com/index1099.html http://apach3.com/index11.html http://apach3.com/index110.html http://apach3.com/index1100.html http://apach3.com/index1101.html http://apach3.com/index1102.html http://apach3.com/index1103.html http://apach3.com/index1104.html http://apach3.com/index1105.html http://apach3.com/index1106.html http://apach3.com/index1107.html http://apach3.com/index1108.html http://apach3.com/index1109.html http://apach3.com/index111.html http://apach3.com/index1110.html http://apach3.com/index1111.html http://apach3.com/index1112.html http://apach3.com/index1113.html http://apach3.com/index1114.html http://apach3.com/index1115.html http://apach3.com/index1116.html http://apach3.com/index1117.html http://apach3.com/index1118.html http://apach3.com/index1119.html http://apach3.com/index112.html http://apach3.com/index1120.html http://apach3.com/index1121.html http://apach3.com/index1122.html http://apach3.com/index1123.html http://apach3.com/index1124.html http://apach3.com/index1125.html http://apach3.com/index1126.html http://apach3.com/index1127.html http://apach3.com/index1128.html http://apach3.com/index1129.html http://apach3.com/index113.html http://apach3.com/index1130.html http://apach3.com/index1131.html http://apach3.com/index1132.html http://apach3.com/index1133.html http://apach3.com/index1134.html http://apach3.com/index1135.html http://apach3.com/index1136.html http://apach3.com/index1137.html http://apach3.com/index1138.html http://apach3.com/index1139.html http://apach3.com/index114.html http://apach3.com/index1140.html http://apach3.com/index1141.html http://apach3.com/index1142.html http://apach3.com/index1143.html http://apach3.com/index1144.html http://apach3.com/index1145.html http://apach3.com/index1146.html http://apach3.com/index1147.html http://apach3.com/index1148.html http://apach3.com/index1149.html http://apach3.com/index115.html http://apach3.com/index1150.html http://apach3.com/index1151.html http://apach3.com/index1152.html http://apach3.com/index1153.html http://apach3.com/index1154.html http://apach3.com/index1155.html http://apach3.com/index1156.html http://apach3.com/index1157.html http://apach3.com/index1158.html http://apach3.com/index1159.html http://apach3.com/index116.html http://apach3.com/index1160.html http://apach3.com/index1161.html http://apach3.com/index1162.html http://apach3.com/index1163.html http://apach3.com/index1164.html http://apach3.com/index1165.html http://apach3.com/index1166.html http://apach3.com/index1167.html http://apach3.com/index1168.html http://apach3.com/index1169.html http://apach3.com/index117.html http://apach3.com/index1170.html http://apach3.com/index1171.html http://apach3.com/index1172.html http://apach3.com/index1173.html http://apach3.com/index1174.html http://apach3.com/index1175.html http://apach3.com/index1176.html http://apach3.com/index1177.html http://apach3.com/index1178.html http://apach3.com/index1179.html http://apach3.com/index118.html http://apach3.com/index1180.html http://apach3.com/index1181.html http://apach3.com/index1182.html http://apach3.com/index1183.html http://apach3.com/index1184.html http://apach3.com/index1185.html http://apach3.com/index1186.html http://apach3.com/index1187.html http://apach3.com/index1188.html http://apach3.com/index1189.html http://apach3.com/index119.html http://apach3.com/index1190.html http://apach3.com/index1191.html http://apach3.com/index1192.html http://apach3.com/index1193.html http://apach3.com/index1194.html http://apach3.com/index1195.html http://apach3.com/index1196.html http://apach3.com/index1197.html http://apach3.com/index1198.html http://apach3.com/index1199.html http://apach3.com/index12.html http://apach3.com/index120.html http://apach3.com/index1200.html http://apach3.com/index1201.html http://apach3.com/index1202.html http://apach3.com/index1203.html http://apach3.com/index1204.html http://apach3.com/index1205.html http://apach3.com/index1206.html http://apach3.com/index1207.html http://apach3.com/index1208.html http://apach3.com/index1209.html http://apach3.com/index121.html http://apach3.com/index1210.html http://apach3.com/index1211.html http://apach3.com/index1212.html http://apach3.com/index1213.html http://apach3.com/index1214.html http://apach3.com/index1215.html http://apach3.com/index1216.html http://apach3.com/index1217.html http://apach3.com/index1218.html http://apach3.com/index1219.html http://apach3.com/index122.html http://apach3.com/index1220.html http://apach3.com/index1221.html http://apach3.com/index1222.html http://apach3.com/index1223.html http://apach3.com/index1224.html http://apach3.com/index1225.html http://apach3.com/index1226.html http://apach3.com/index1227.html http://apach3.com/index1228.html http://apach3.com/index1229.html http://apach3.com/index123.html http://apach3.com/index1230.html http://apach3.com/index1231.html http://apach3.com/index1232.html http://apach3.com/index1233.html http://apach3.com/index1234.html http://apach3.com/index1235.html http://apach3.com/index1236.html http://apach3.com/index1237.html http://apach3.com/index1238.html http://apach3.com/index1239.html http://apach3.com/index124.html http://apach3.com/index1240.html http://apach3.com/index1241.html http://apach3.com/index1242.html http://apach3.com/index1243.html http://apach3.com/index1244.html http://apach3.com/index1245.html http://apach3.com/index1246.html http://apach3.com/index1247.html http://apach3.com/index1248.html http://apach3.com/index1249.html http://apach3.com/index125.html http://apach3.com/index1250.html http://apach3.com/index1251.html http://apach3.com/index1252.html http://apach3.com/index1253.html http://apach3.com/index1254.html http://apach3.com/index1255.html http://apach3.com/index1256.html http://apach3.com/index1257.html http://apach3.com/index1258.html http://apach3.com/index1259.html http://apach3.com/index126.html http://apach3.com/index1260.html http://apach3.com/index1261.html http://apach3.com/index1262.html http://apach3.com/index1263.html http://apach3.com/index1264.html http://apach3.com/index1265.html http://apach3.com/index1266.html http://apach3.com/index1267.html http://apach3.com/index1268.html http://apach3.com/index1269.html http://apach3.com/index127.html http://apach3.com/index1270.html http://apach3.com/index1271.html http://apach3.com/index1272.html http://apach3.com/index1273.html http://apach3.com/index1274.html http://apach3.com/index1275.html http://apach3.com/index1276.html http://apach3.com/index1277.html http://apach3.com/index1278.html http://apach3.com/index1279.html http://apach3.com/index128.html http://apach3.com/index1280.html http://apach3.com/index1281.html http://apach3.com/index1282.html http://apach3.com/index1283.html http://apach3.com/index1284.html http://apach3.com/index1285.html http://apach3.com/index1286.html http://apach3.com/index1287.html http://apach3.com/index1288.html http://apach3.com/index1289.html http://apach3.com/index129.html http://apach3.com/index1290.html http://apach3.com/index1291.html http://apach3.com/index1292.html http://apach3.com/index1293.html http://apach3.com/index1294.html http://apach3.com/index1295.html http://apach3.com/index1296.html http://apach3.com/index1297.html http://apach3.com/index1298.html http://apach3.com/index1299.html http://apach3.com/index13.html http://apach3.com/index130.html http://apach3.com/index1300.html http://apach3.com/index1301.html http://apach3.com/index1302.html http://apach3.com/index1303.html http://apach3.com/index1304.html http://apach3.com/index1305.html http://apach3.com/index1306.html http://apach3.com/index1307.html http://apach3.com/index1308.html http://apach3.com/index1309.html http://apach3.com/index131.html http://apach3.com/index1310.html http://apach3.com/index1311.html http://apach3.com/index1312.html http://apach3.com/index1313.html http://apach3.com/index1314.html http://apach3.com/index1315.html http://apach3.com/index1316.html http://apach3.com/index1317.html http://apach3.com/index1318.html http://apach3.com/index1319.html http://apach3.com/index132.html http://apach3.com/index1320.html http://apach3.com/index1321.html http://apach3.com/index1322.html http://apach3.com/index1323.html http://apach3.com/index1324.html http://apach3.com/index1325.html http://apach3.com/index1326.html http://apach3.com/index1327.html http://apach3.com/index1328.html http://apach3.com/index1329.html http://apach3.com/index133.html http://apach3.com/index1330.html http://apach3.com/index1331.html http://apach3.com/index1332.html http://apach3.com/index1333.html http://apach3.com/index1334.html http://apach3.com/index1335.html http://apach3.com/index1336.html http://apach3.com/index1337.html http://apach3.com/index1338.html http://apach3.com/index1339.html http://apach3.com/index134.html http://apach3.com/index1340.html http://apach3.com/index1341.html http://apach3.com/index1342.html http://apach3.com/index1343.html http://apach3.com/index1344.html http://apach3.com/index1345.html http://apach3.com/index1346.html http://apach3.com/index1347.html http://apach3.com/index1348.html http://apach3.com/index1349.html http://apach3.com/index135.html http://apach3.com/index1350.html http://apach3.com/index1351.html http://apach3.com/index1352.html http://apach3.com/index1353.html http://apach3.com/index1354.html http://apach3.com/index1355.html http://apach3.com/index1356.html http://apach3.com/index1357.html http://apach3.com/index1358.html http://apach3.com/index1359.html http://apach3.com/index136.html http://apach3.com/index1360.html http://apach3.com/index1361.html http://apach3.com/index1362.html http://apach3.com/index1363.html http://apach3.com/index1364.html http://apach3.com/index1365.html http://apach3.com/index1366.html http://apach3.com/index1367.html http://apach3.com/index1368.html http://apach3.com/index1369.html http://apach3.com/index137.html http://apach3.com/index1370.html http://apach3.com/index1371.html http://apach3.com/index1372.html http://apach3.com/index1373.html http://apach3.com/index1374.html http://apach3.com/index1375.html http://apach3.com/index1376.html http://apach3.com/index1377.html http://apach3.com/index1378.html http://apach3.com/index1379.html http://apach3.com/index138.html http://apach3.com/index1380.html http://apach3.com/index1381.html http://apach3.com/index1382.html http://apach3.com/index1383.html http://apach3.com/index1384.html http://apach3.com/index1385.html http://apach3.com/index1386.html http://apach3.com/index1387.html http://apach3.com/index1388.html http://apach3.com/index1389.html http://apach3.com/index139.html http://apach3.com/index1390.html http://apach3.com/index1391.html http://apach3.com/index1392.html http://apach3.com/index1393.html http://apach3.com/index1394.html http://apach3.com/index1395.html http://apach3.com/index1396.html http://apach3.com/index1397.html http://apach3.com/index1398.html http://apach3.com/index1399.html http://apach3.com/index14.html http://apach3.com/index140.html http://apach3.com/index1400.html http://apach3.com/index1401.html http://apach3.com/index1402.html http://apach3.com/index1403.html http://apach3.com/index1404.html http://apach3.com/index1405.html http://apach3.com/index1406.html http://apach3.com/index1407.html http://apach3.com/index1408.html http://apach3.com/index1409.html http://apach3.com/index141.html http://apach3.com/index1410.html http://apach3.com/index1411.html http://apach3.com/index1412.html http://apach3.com/index1413.html http://apach3.com/index1414.html http://apach3.com/index1415.html http://apach3.com/index1416.html http://apach3.com/index1417.html http://apach3.com/index1418.html http://apach3.com/index1419.html http://apach3.com/index142.html http://apach3.com/index1420.html http://apach3.com/index1421.html http://apach3.com/index1422.html http://apach3.com/index1423.html http://apach3.com/index1424.html http://apach3.com/index1425.html http://apach3.com/index1426.html http://apach3.com/index1427.html http://apach3.com/index1428.html http://apach3.com/index1429.html http://apach3.com/index143.html http://apach3.com/index1430.html http://apach3.com/index1431.html http://apach3.com/index1432.html http://apach3.com/index1433.html http://apach3.com/index1434.html http://apach3.com/index1435.html http://apach3.com/index1436.html http://apach3.com/index1437.html http://apach3.com/index1438.html http://apach3.com/index1439.html http://apach3.com/index144.html http://apach3.com/index1440.html http://apach3.com/index1441.html http://apach3.com/index1442.html http://apach3.com/index1443.html http://apach3.com/index1444.html http://apach3.com/index1445.html http://apach3.com/index1446.html http://apach3.com/index1447.html http://apach3.com/index1448.html http://apach3.com/index1449.html http://apach3.com/index145.html http://apach3.com/index1450.html http://apach3.com/index1451.html http://apach3.com/index1452.html http://apach3.com/index1453.html http://apach3.com/index1454.html http://apach3.com/index1455.html http://apach3.com/index1456.html http://apach3.com/index1457.html http://apach3.com/index1458.html http://apach3.com/index1459.html http://apach3.com/index146.html http://apach3.com/index1460.html http://apach3.com/index1461.html http://apach3.com/index1462.html http://apach3.com/index1463.html http://apach3.com/index1464.html http://apach3.com/index1465.html http://apach3.com/index1466.html http://apach3.com/index1467.html http://apach3.com/index1468.html http://apach3.com/index1469.html http://apach3.com/index147.html http://apach3.com/index1470.html http://apach3.com/index1471.html http://apach3.com/index1472.html http://apach3.com/index1473.html http://apach3.com/index1474.html http://apach3.com/index1475.html http://apach3.com/index1476.html http://apach3.com/index1477.html http://apach3.com/index1478.html http://apach3.com/index1479.html http://apach3.com/index148.html http://apach3.com/index1480.html http://apach3.com/index1481.html http://apach3.com/index1482.html http://apach3.com/index1483.html http://apach3.com/index1484.html http://apach3.com/index1485.html http://apach3.com/index1486.html http://apach3.com/index1487.html http://apach3.com/index1488.html http://apach3.com/index1489.html http://apach3.com/index149.html http://apach3.com/index1490.html http://apach3.com/index1491.html http://apach3.com/index1492.html http://apach3.com/index1493.html http://apach3.com/index1494.html http://apach3.com/index1495.html http://apach3.com/index1496.html http://apach3.com/index1497.html http://apach3.com/index1498.html http://apach3.com/index1499.html http://apach3.com/index15.html http://apach3.com/index150.html http://apach3.com/index1500.html http://apach3.com/index1501.html http://apach3.com/index1502.html http://apach3.com/index1503.html http://apach3.com/index1504.html http://apach3.com/index1505.html http://apach3.com/index1506.html http://apach3.com/index1507.html http://apach3.com/index1508.html http://apach3.com/index1509.html http://apach3.com/index151.html http://apach3.com/index1510.html http://apach3.com/index1511.html http://apach3.com/index1512.html http://apach3.com/index1513.html http://apach3.com/index1514.html http://apach3.com/index1515.html http://apach3.com/index1516.html http://apach3.com/index1517.html http://apach3.com/index1518.html http://apach3.com/index1519.html http://apach3.com/index152.html http://apach3.com/index1520.html http://apach3.com/index1521.html http://apach3.com/index1522.html http://apach3.com/index1523.html http://apach3.com/index1524.html http://apach3.com/index1525.html http://apach3.com/index1526.html http://apach3.com/index1527.html http://apach3.com/index1528.html http://apach3.com/index1529.html http://apach3.com/index153.html http://apach3.com/index1530.html http://apach3.com/index1531.html http://apach3.com/index1532.html http://apach3.com/index1533.html http://apach3.com/index1534.html http://apach3.com/index1535.html http://apach3.com/index1536.html http://apach3.com/index1537.html http://apach3.com/index1538.html http://apach3.com/index1539.html http://apach3.com/index154.html http://apach3.com/index1540.html http://apach3.com/index1541.html http://apach3.com/index1542.html http://apach3.com/index1543.html http://apach3.com/index1544.html http://apach3.com/index1545.html http://apach3.com/index1546.html http://apach3.com/index1547.html http://apach3.com/index1548.html http://apach3.com/index1549.html http://apach3.com/index155.html http://apach3.com/index1550.html http://apach3.com/index1551.html http://apach3.com/index1552.html http://apach3.com/index1553.html http://apach3.com/index1554.html http://apach3.com/index1555.html http://apach3.com/index1556.html http://apach3.com/index1557.html http://apach3.com/index1558.html http://apach3.com/index1559.html http://apach3.com/index156.html http://apach3.com/index1560.html http://apach3.com/index1561.html http://apach3.com/index1562.html http://apach3.com/index1563.html http://apach3.com/index1564.html http://apach3.com/index1565.html http://apach3.com/index1566.html http://apach3.com/index1567.html http://apach3.com/index1568.html http://apach3.com/index1569.html http://apach3.com/index157.html http://apach3.com/index1570.html http://apach3.com/index1571.html http://apach3.com/index1572.html http://apach3.com/index1573.html http://apach3.com/index1574.html http://apach3.com/index1575.html http://apach3.com/index1576.html http://apach3.com/index1577.html http://apach3.com/index1578.html http://apach3.com/index1579.html http://apach3.com/index158.html http://apach3.com/index1580.html http://apach3.com/index1581.html http://apach3.com/index1582.html http://apach3.com/index1583.html http://apach3.com/index1584.html http://apach3.com/index1585.html http://apach3.com/index1586.html http://apach3.com/index1587.html http://apach3.com/index1588.html http://apach3.com/index1589.html http://apach3.com/index159.html http://apach3.com/index1590.html http://apach3.com/index1591.html http://apach3.com/index1592.html http://apach3.com/index1593.html http://apach3.com/index1594.html http://apach3.com/index1595.html http://apach3.com/index1596.html http://apach3.com/index1597.html http://apach3.com/index1598.html http://apach3.com/index1599.html http://apach3.com/index16.html http://apach3.com/index160.html http://apach3.com/index1600.html http://apach3.com/index1601.html http://apach3.com/index1602.html http://apach3.com/index1603.html http://apach3.com/index1604.html http://apach3.com/index1605.html http://apach3.com/index1606.html http://apach3.com/index1607.html http://apach3.com/index1608.html http://apach3.com/index1609.html http://apach3.com/index161.html http://apach3.com/index1610.html http://apach3.com/index1611.html http://apach3.com/index1612.html http://apach3.com/index1613.html http://apach3.com/index1614.html http://apach3.com/index1615.html http://apach3.com/index1616.html http://apach3.com/index1617.html http://apach3.com/index1618.html http://apach3.com/index1619.html http://apach3.com/index162.html http://apach3.com/index1620.html http://apach3.com/index1621.html http://apach3.com/index1622.html http://apach3.com/index1623.html http://apach3.com/index1624.html http://apach3.com/index1625.html http://apach3.com/index1626.html http://apach3.com/index1627.html http://apach3.com/index1628.html http://apach3.com/index1629.html http://apach3.com/index163.html http://apach3.com/index1630.html http://apach3.com/index1631.html http://apach3.com/index1632.html http://apach3.com/index1633.html http://apach3.com/index1634.html http://apach3.com/index1635.html http://apach3.com/index1636.html http://apach3.com/index1637.html http://apach3.com/index1638.html http://apach3.com/index1639.html http://apach3.com/index164.html http://apach3.com/index1640.html http://apach3.com/index1641.html http://apach3.com/index1642.html http://apach3.com/index1643.html http://apach3.com/index1644.html http://apach3.com/index1645.html http://apach3.com/index1646.html http://apach3.com/index1647.html http://apach3.com/index1648.html http://apach3.com/index1649.html http://apach3.com/index165.html http://apach3.com/index1650.html http://apach3.com/index1651.html http://apach3.com/index1652.html http://apach3.com/index1653.html http://apach3.com/index1654.html

Stated by: moriana on February 12, 2006 9:46 PM

strapon anal dildo movie clip* super anal first timer* free mature monster* free mature moon* bigtitsroundass pics* bigtitsroundass rogue* all internall com* all internall movies* veronika assparade* ebony phat bootie girls* mff double penetration* mff garage orgy*

Stated by: bundlebox on July 13, 2006 3:42 PM