March 15
2004
Come on you yids
» Posted on March 15, 2004 02:46 AM » Category: Culture

Excellent piece in The Times by Julia Magnet on being Jewish in Britain:

...Jewish culture is at the edge of British society, an opinion confirmed by my long tenure here. There is no British Philip Roth or Saul Bellow, not even a Mel Brooks.

..Like everyone else in New York, I’m only half-Jewish, and the wrong half at that, but I’m all Jewish American Princess. Mine is, after all, the only city that could be dismissed with a racist epithet — Jesse Jackson’s “Hymie-town” — and embrace said slur, applying it gleefully at any occasion. In Hymie-town, which sets the cultural agenda for elite America, even Italians have passable Yiddish and there ’s a synagogue every fifth block. There’s no need, then, for New York Jews to cling to each other, to fret about marrying out. There is no out — Jews have influenced and been accepted by urban American culture: take Broadway’s most popular show, the Jewish-fest, The Producers. Of course, mothers still nag: “It’s just as easy to fall in love with a Jew, as a shaygetz,” but their world doesn’t end if the boy’s a goy.

...Notwithstanding half-Jewish Michael Howard, Jewish culture is still quite hidden in Britain. It could be the legacy of T. E Laurence-style Arabism, or a culture clash between gentlemanly amateurism and the “may you grow up to be a doctor” Jewish work ethic. But the less open a society, the more closed and protective its Jewish culture will be...

Just one small quibble: turning a racialist epithet on itself, and embracing it, is not just the preserve of New Yorkers. Spurs fans long ago responded to the chants of 'yids' and now scream 'yiddo' and 'come on you yids' at every opportunity (to good effect this afternoon, when we beat the cheats of Newscastle 1-0).


MessageSpace
Comments

It's not a new problem with anglo-Jewry. During the war, a desire not to "stand out" impeded attempts to get the Holocaust taken seriously by the Foreign Office, BBC etc.
Even recently, many people in the "community" were upset with the way certain organisations aggressively attacked Jenny Tonge for her idiotic comments about suicide bombing,
Despite a real result being obtained - no one now will say such things without realising they could face severe consequences - more conservative elements winced at the sight of Jewish muscle being deployed so obviously.
Perhaps the real reason is that anglo-Jewry regards itself much more as being more a private members club than a community. It speaks to itself, it looks inwards, it minimises any appearance of dissent and looks on divergent opinions as treasonous (see Kaufman).
Another point - I see Ms Magnet see herself as Jewish but has a gentile mother. Still, she feels drawn to the community and identifies with it.
How many people with the same family pattern in the UK do so. A tiny minority, I would guess. I wonder what that should tell us....

Stated by: mcg on March 15, 2004 2:40 PM

I think Magnet was, as she said, talking about the entire city being dismissed with a racial epithet and embracing it. After all, it's not just black people in New York who have altered the n-word's final syllable and turned it into a term of endearment and respect.

Stated by: Jackie D on March 15, 2004 6:08 PM
Stated by: Krystyna z gazowni on May 9, 2006 8:17 AM
Post a comment

    


    •